The practical difference

Compare Duffy + Duffy Cost Segregation alternatives around the commercial building and records involved. AE Tax Advisors offers standalone studies; McGuire Sponsel describes a site-inspected engineering approach; Cost Segregation Guys offers virtual or in-person workflows. Compare component investigation, final schedules and CPA support for equivalent work.

AE offers standalone cost segregation studies at $1 per square foot, with a $2,000 minimum per study. AE Tax Advisors provides tax planning for business owners and real estate investors as a separate service. Advisory, return preparation, amendments and other implementation work are separately scoped and priced.

Published by AE Tax Advisors, a competing service provider. This is a commercial comparison of public service information, not an independent ranking or firsthand customer review. Sources checked November 6, 2026; confirm current availability and fees directly.

Compare the engagement

DecisionDuffy + Duffy Cost SegregationAE Tax Advisors
Public modelDuffy + Duffy describes engineering-based cost segregation involving CPAs, construction engineers and estimators, including work on commercial and LEED-certified buildings.A standalone cost segregation study, with advisory and return work separately scoped.
Implementation and filingAsk who reviews the report with your CPA, what depreciation schedules are supplied, and whether method-change documentation, Form 3115 preparation or return work is part of a separate engagement. The reviewed pages do not establish those inclusions.Agree on the professional responsible for each task. Returns, amendments, studies and additional work have separate scopes and prices.
Fees and supportSee sourced fees and scope questions$1 per square foot, $2,000 minimum per study. Confirm inspection, support and separately scoped tax work.
Key buying questionWhat inspection and engineering investigation are included for this building?What property investigation, component schedules, support and preparer handoff does AE include, and which implementation tasks require separate scope?

Choose Duffy + Duffy Cost Segregation when its proposal matches these needs

Keep Duffy + Duffy on your shortlist for an engineering-based commercial study, including a new or existing building or a LEED-certified project. Its website describes a team with accounting, engineering and estimating experience.

Consider AE for this situation

Suppose you completed an energy-efficient office building and already have a CPA handling the return. Compare the engineering study, treatment of construction records and any separately scoped energy-related work.

Keep the provider whose proposal addresses the building’s technical details and your preparer’s required documentation. Compare the study fee and any additional specialty work separately.

AE can scope a standalone study and discuss separately contracted advisory or return work. Retain your existing preparer when that arrangement fits, and agree on the report handoff before work begins. Neither provider is the universal choice. A discovery call determines potential fit; detailed analysis follows an agreed engagement.

Ask for a proposal you can compare

  • What inspection and engineering investigation are included for this building?
  • How are construction records and building components documented?
  • Who answers my CPA’s questions and supplies the final schedules?
  • Are energy-related analysis, forms or tax-return services separately contracted?

Give each firm the same property address, square footage, closing statement, placed-in-service date, improvement records and existing depreciation schedules. Identify the owner entity, return preparer and deadline. Request a written scope for inspection, engineering analysis, report schedules, support and separately billed implementation. Send sensitive records through the firm’s secure intake process.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Duffy + Duffy Cost Segregation or AE Tax Advisors a better fit?

Keep the provider whose proposal addresses the building’s technical details and your preparer’s required documentation. Compare the study fee and any additional specialty work separately.

Can I keep my existing tax preparer?

Ask how the study report and schedules will be delivered to your preparer. Identify who evaluates any accounting-method change, prepares required forms, signs the return and handles follow-up questions. AE’s responsibilities depend on the agreed scope.

Official sources and research date

Service descriptions are attributed to the linked provider websites. AE has not independently verified advertised savings, customer outcomes or service delivery. A public service menu does not establish the contents of your engagement.

Researched November 6, 2026 by AE Tax Advisors. No customer star rating or universal winner is assigned.

Talk Through Your Situation

Discuss your priorities, upcoming decisions and whether a study or advisory engagement fits. Detailed analysis, implementation or filing work follows an agreed written scope.

The decision to resolve before choosing Duffy + Duffy Cost Segregation or AE

You have construction plans and invoices and want to know how a detailed technical review would use them.

How will construction records affect the study methodology?

Ask which site information and cost records support the study and what deliverables reach the CPA.

Ask both firms to put the answer, responsible professional, deliverables and deadline into the proposal. This checklist does not assert that either provider omits a service; the signed scope establishes who completes the work.

Duffy + Duffy Cost Segregation fee evidence and quote questions · Other Duffy + Duffy Cost Segregation alternatives

Compare the full 100-firm directory by your needs

Business Owners: Are You Overpaying on Taxes?

Book a Cost Seg Discovery Call