SurePayroll vs OnPay: Small-Team Payroll and the Complete Fee Schedule
Compare SurePayroll and OnPay by filing scope, annual forms, integrations and the work a small employer must retain.
The decision to make
SurePayroll and OnPay both serve small employers seeking payroll processing and tax-filing support. Compare the specific service and the full year of charges rather than only a monthly headline. The business should also define how time records, approvals and payroll results move between employees, administrators and accounting.
Compare the documented scope
| Decision | First option | Second option |
|---|---|---|
| Core offer | Confirm SurePayroll Full Service. | OnPay Payroll Essentials. |
| Year-end forms | Separate annual base and per-form charges described. | Year-end filings and forms described as included. |
| Optional tools | Accounting and time integrations separately priced. | Time and HR products or bundles separately selected. |
Specify what the small team actually needs
For a fictional seven-person dental office, identify who collects hours, checks changes and approves payroll while the owner is unavailable. Give both providers that workflow and ask them to demonstrate it. An employee portal does not automatically provide supervisor approval, and an integration does not guarantee correct account mapping. Include any employees working in another state and ask how their accounts and filings are supported.
Build the first-year and ongoing totals
OnPay lists Payroll Essentials at $49 monthly plus $6 per paid worker, producing $91 for seven workers before add-ons. SurePayroll’s public page contains multiple starting-price presentations, so obtain the applicable offer and per-employee terms directly. Include its annual $50 base plus $5-per-form year-end charge and any chosen integration fees. Keep temporary promotions separate from the ordinary recurring schedule. The goal is a matched complete quote, not a claim that one advertised number is always cheaper.
Review the conversion and exception path
Ask who imports year-to-date records, verifies totals and files for a period spanning the switch. Supply the same source records to both providers and retain the accepted opening reconciliation. Establish how a missing timesheet, rejected payment or corrected worker address is escalated. The employer should maintain access to reports and confirmations and continue to review inputs even when the service handles routine filing operations.
Build a written selection brief
- Actual small-team approval workflow and backup administrator.
- Work locations, pay schedules and required time connections.
- First-year and recurring totals with forms and add-ons.
- Opening balances and transition-period filing ownership.
- Correction procedures, retained reports and support contacts.
Test access during an absence
Have the proposed backup administrator describe how they would review and release a routine payroll if the owner were unavailable. Verify permissions without sharing credentials and identify the records needed for approval. This concrete exercise can expose a workflow gap that a generic feature comparison would miss.
Publisher and review context
AE Tax Advisors publishes this commercial research and offers advisory services. No affiliation with the providers or independent ranking is implied. Confirm current fees and the written engagement before purchasing.
Official sources
Reviewed November 20, 2026.
Related Reading
Talk Through Your Situation
Discuss your priorities, upcoming decisions and whether a study or advisory engagement fits. Detailed analysis, implementation or filing work follows an agreed written scope.