The decision to make

OnPay Payroll Essentials and Patriot Full Service both describe payroll-tax filing services, making them a more useful scope match than comparing OnPay with Patriot Basic. The decision then turns on workers paid, state footprint, required workforce tools and the way payroll records reach accounting. Confirm the complete proposal before drawing a price conclusion.

Compare the documented scope

Documented scope comparison
DecisionFirst optionSecond option
Ordinary monthly formulaOnPay: $49 plus $6 per paid worker.Patriot Full Service: $37 plus $5 per worker paid.
Additional statesMultistate payroll included.Published $12 monthly per additional state.
Workforce toolsSeparate HR/time products and bundles.Separate HR/time add-ons.

Build the actual monthly example

For a fictional employer paying ten workers, the published base formulas produce $109 for OnPay and $87 for Patriot Full Service before extras. If multiple states or workforce add-ons apply, those totals change. List workers actually paid, work locations and the tools needed for time approvals or employee records. Ask how inactive workers and corrections affect billing. The lowest unconfigured starting number does not establish the lower cost for the company’s real payroll.

Review the filing and conversion scope

Ask both providers which accounts they will file for, how notices are handled and what records are needed to begin. Do not assume a new subscription includes correcting previous periods. During a conversion, assign ownership for each quarter and year-end form and verify year-to-date totals. OnPay describes year-end filings within its plan, and Patriot Full Service describes year-end payroll-tax filings without an additional fee; confirm the actual forms needed by this workforce.

Test the work done by the employer

Use one sample hourly employee and one salary change to examine approvals, reports and the accounting handoff. Check whether the proposed time tool is included or separate and how it sends approved hours. A tax-filing service still depends on accurate wage and location information. Name the person who approves payroll and keeps evidence of payments and filings, and establish an escalation path when source records or account credentials are missing.

Build a written selection brief

  • Workers paid, work locations and required tax accounts.
  • Ordinary total including additional states and chosen add-ons.
  • Quarter and year-end responsibilities during the switch.
  • Time approvals, rate changes and accounting output.
  • Named reviewer, evidence retention and exception contacts.

Check employee access after departure

Ask how a former employee receives historical pay information and year-end documents, and what the administrator must do before removing access. Record the process in the company’s offboarding checklist. This ordinary workflow is easier to evaluate in advance than after a worker has already left.

Publisher and review context

AE Tax Advisors publishes this commercial research and offers advisory services. No affiliation with the providers or independent ranking is implied. Confirm current fees and the written engagement before purchasing.

Talk Through Your Situation

Discuss your priorities, upcoming decisions and whether a study or advisory engagement fits. Detailed analysis, implementation or filing work follows an agreed written scope.

Business Owners: Are You Overpaying on Taxes?

Book a Call