Gusto vs OnPay: State Coverage, Time Tools and Monthly Cost
Compare Gusto and OnPay through a matched workforce, state coverage, time tracking and add-on requirements.
The decision to make
Gusto and OnPay publish similar entry-level base-and-worker formulas, but the starting products have different scope. Gusto Simple is described for one-state payroll, while OnPay Payroll Essentials includes multistate payroll. Compare the actual workforce and required time or HR tools instead of assuming identical starting numbers mean identical services.
Compare the documented scope
| Decision | First option | Second option |
|---|---|---|
| Entry monthly formula | Gusto Simple: $49 plus $6 per person. | OnPay Essentials: $49 plus $6 per paid worker. |
| State coverage | Simple single-state; Plus multistate. | Multistate included in Essentials. |
| Time and HR | Plan-specific features and add-ons. | Modular time and HR products/bundles. |
Use the same employee scenario
For a fictional eight-person firm hiring its first out-of-state worker, list the work locations, payroll schedule and approvals. Ask Gusto which plan or services are required and ask OnPay to confirm the same setup. Do not treat a mailing address as a complete analysis of payroll obligations. The company must supply the relevant facts and confirm any registration steps. If historical work locations were entered incorrectly, scope the correction separately from the prospective software choice.
Price the recurring workflow
At eight paid people, the entry formulas both produce $97 monthly before extras, but that arithmetic does not establish equivalent coverage. If Gusto Plus is needed, its $80 base plus $12 per person changes the calculation. OnPay now lists separate time and HR products and bundles; do not rely on an old description that all HR functionality is included at one rate. Ask for the exact selected configuration and identify benefit premiums, optional support and other services separately.
Compare approval and reconciliation
Give both providers a sample new hire, a pay-rate change and a corrected time entry. Ask who can approve each action and what audit trail the company receives. Review how payroll entries map into accounting and how year-end information is retained. The provider can support processing and filings within the agreed scope, but the employer still needs accurate records and a named person to review the payroll before it is released.
Build a written selection brief
- The same paid-worker count, locations and pay schedule.
- Required time, PTO, HR and support features.
- Complete recurring quote with optional products identified.
- New-hire, rate-change and correction demonstrations.
- Accounting mapping, approval ownership and record access.
Evaluate seasonal staffing
If the business adds temporary workers, ask both providers how the paid-person count changes and how inactive records remain accessible. Run the quote with a normal month and a peak month. Keep those two scenarios explicit instead of using one average headcount that hides the bill in the busiest period.
Publisher and review context
AE Tax Advisors publishes this commercial research and offers advisory services. No affiliation with the providers or independent ranking is implied. Confirm current fees and the written engagement before purchasing.
Official sources
Reviewed November 20, 2026.
Related Reading
Talk Through Your Situation
Discuss your priorities, upcoming decisions and whether a study or advisory engagement fits. Detailed analysis, implementation or filing work follows an agreed written scope.