Start with the contribution policy

A new retirement plan should reflect what the employer and employees need to do, not simply the smallest advertised base charge. Gusto Retirement describes Starter as a limited plan without employer contributions or plan loans. Core includes standard plan design options and employer contributions such as matching and profit sharing. These differences matter before comparing invoices. An employer that intends to make contributions should discuss the appropriate plan design rather than assume a lower-priced option can be adapted after payroll has begun.

Separate platform selection from eligibility review

Gusto’s current help center identifies restrictions on who may use Starter and on when a move to another plan can occur. Ask the provider to assess the actual employer history and proposed start date. Do not read the word Starter as a general label for any newly created plan. This comparison does not establish that a business qualifies or state contribution limits. Use the governing documents and professional review for those questions, especially when related companies or another existing retirement arrangement may be relevant.

A fictional first-plan decision

Consider a fictional employer with a small workforce and a plan to contribute company money next year. The owner initially compares only the monthly charges. A more useful brief states the planned contribution, the employee population, the expected payroll start and who will administer changes. The provider can then explain which offering supports those requirements. If the owner instead expects an employee-funded arrangement, the brief should still identify what happens if that policy changes. The decision should not depend on a guessed ability to upgrade immediately.

Build a complete fee comparison

Gusto states a monthly base charge and a separate charge per active participant, plus an annual account fee. Active participant has a specific billing definition, so headcount alone is not the right multiplier. Ask how employer-paid account fees, additional charges and plan changes would appear on the invoice. Compare an initial year and an ongoing year without subtracting assumed tax credits. A quote should also identify which fees are paid by the company and which come from participant accounts.

Questions before signing

Ask the provider to confirm the plan design, employer contribution capability, loan policy, participant billing definition and permitted change dates in writing. Identify who sends employee information, reviews payroll exceptions and handles a missed or corrected contribution. Request a transition plan if business needs change. Outsourcing functions does not remove the sponsor’s role in selecting and monitoring providers. The useful outcome is a documented fit for the employer’s intended policy, with responsibility and fees understood before adoption, not a claim that one tier is always better.

Publication and fee context

AE Tax Advisors publishes this commercial research and offers tax-advisory services. No provider affiliation or independent rating is implied. Sources checked November 21, 2026. Provider terms can change; request current written scope and complete fee disclosures. This comparison does not recommend investments, determine plan eligibility or promise tax savings.

Talk Through Your Situation

Discuss your priorities, upcoming decisions and whether a study or advisory engagement fits. Detailed analysis, implementation or filing work follows an agreed written scope.

Business Owners: Are You Overpaying on Taxes?

Book a Call