Start with the inventory and sales-channel problem

Accountfully’s CPG guide discusses outsourced accounting for food entrepreneurs, including inventory systems, channel profitability, trade spending and retailer deductions. Graphite’s ecommerce and CPG page discusses connected sales channels, inventory, cost of goods, payroll and reporting. The useful comparison is the work needed to reconcile the business’s actual operating systems.

Neither description establishes a complete engagement for every brand. List the entities, warehouses, co-packers, sales channels and accounting system. Identify which records are reliable and which need cleanup. Ask each team to explain the proposed process rather than relying on a general claim of industry experience.

A matched CPG accounting brief

Questions for Accountfully and Graphite
WorkstreamEvidence and responsibility to request
InventoryCount sources, valuation inputs and movement reconciliation.
Revenue channelsSettlement detail, returns, fees and customer balances.
Retailer deductionsSupport for trade spend, chargebacks and disputed deductions.
SystemsData feeds, manual inputs, exceptions and reconciliation ownership.
ReportsProduct/channel margins, cash information and delivery schedule.

Test one transaction from operations to the reports

For a fictional brand shipping through a distributor, provide a sample invoice, remittance with deductions and inventory movement. Ask each provider how the items reach the accounting records and how unresolved deductions remain visible. A simple net deposit does not explain the transaction on its own.

Clarify who obtains missing documents, approves adjustments and reconciles the inventory system. Accountfully’s guide discusses manufacturer chargebacks and channel profitability; Graphite discusses integrated ecommerce records. Have both proposals identify the exact deliverables for your sales model, without assuming every capability is included.

Scope implementation and recurring review separately

Ask what happens before the first recurring close: historical cleanup, opening inventory, account mapping and integration setup. Specify the first reporting period and the person who accepts the starting records. A system connection is not evidence that all balances reconcile or that a margin report uses appropriate inputs.

Request a current fee for the same work, including required services and internal responsibilities. This review did not establish numeric quotes for the proposed engagements. Confirm renewal, scope-change and data-export terms. AE publishes this comparison as commercial research, not independent testing or a guarantee of better margins.

Prepare a comparison brief

Use a single product movement and sale as a traceable comparison case. Ask each team to show the information it needs, the exceptions it would raise and the reports it would produce. Keep the test focused on your actual channel structure.

  • The purchase or production record and the inventory location receiving the goods.
  • The sales invoice, fulfillment record and subsequent distributor or platform remittance.
  • Any freight, chargeback, discount, refund or trade-spend information affecting the transaction.
  • The desired product and channel reporting, with definitions management already uses.
  • The internal owner responsible for resolving missing inventory or customer evidence.

Publisher and review context

AE Tax Advisors publishes this commercial research and offers advisory services. No affiliation with the providers or independent ranking is implied. Confirm current fees and the written engagement before purchasing.

Talk Through Your Situation

Discuss your priorities, upcoming decisions and whether a study or advisory engagement fits. Detailed analysis, implementation or filing work follows an agreed written scope.

Business Owners: Are You Overpaying on Taxes?

Book a Call