Compare the operating work rather than a sample price

Accountfully’s CPG guide describes accounting support for businesses dealing with inventory, co-packers, sales channels and retailer deductions. Acuity’s pricing page illustrates different client engagements with different service mixes. A published illustration is not a quote for a CPG brand and should not be used as a universal entry price.

Start with the company’s own records: product list, stock locations, sales channels, systems and current close process. Describe the accounting problem the provider must solve. An outsourced team needs enough detail to distinguish a recurring close from a cleanup or implementation project.

What a comparable proposal should identify

CPG scope questions for both providers
AreaRequired detail
InventorySources for quantities, costs and adjustments.
Channel salesGross sales, fees, deductions, returns and settlement timing.
ReportingProduct/channel views, statements and review meetings.
Review roleBookkeeper, accountant/controller and management responsibilities.
PriceInitial project fees and recurring work for the same scope.

Use a CPG example to make differences concrete

For a fictional business selling both online and through retailers, ask how each provider reconciles settlements and explains different gross-margin results by channel. Include a retailer deduction and a stock transfer in the example. Have the team show the requested output with confidential client details removed.

Accountfully describes attention to standard costs, trade spend and distributor relationships. Ask Acuity to specify the corresponding work in its proposed engagement. Do not infer that either firm lacks a capability merely because it is not prominent on the reviewed page; obtain a direct scope answer.

Evaluate the first close and continuing relationship

Ask who prepares opening balances, reviews historical inventory and documents recurring adjustments. Define the date of the first completed reporting package and what information your staff must deliver. A quote that assumes clean records is not equivalent to one that includes resolving old differences.

Acuity’s public examples vary substantially by service mix, and this review did not establish an Accountfully numeric quote. Compare actual proposals, including communication, renewal and export arrangements. AE’s comparison does not rank quality or guarantee a particular operating result.

Prepare a comparison brief

Ask the providers to evaluate the same product-and-channel reporting brief. The aim is to make the specialized work visible without assuming every CPG company needs the same service bundle. Require the proposal to distinguish regular processing from implementation and advisory projects.

  • The inventory and sales systems, their administrators and the reports each can export.
  • A sample retailer deduction and the documents available to resolve its accounting.
  • The channels, products and customer groups management needs to compare consistently.
  • The opening stock or historical-record issues that require a separate cleanup decision.
  • The recurring report, review meeting and quote line associated with each requested output.

Publisher and review context

AE Tax Advisors publishes this commercial research and offers advisory services. No affiliation with the providers or independent ranking is implied. Confirm current fees and the written engagement before purchasing.

Talk Through Your Situation

Discuss your priorities, upcoming decisions and whether a study or advisory engagement fits. Detailed analysis, implementation or filing work follows an agreed written scope.

Business Owners: Are You Overpaying on Taxes?

Book a Call